Skip to the text
Last Chapteron novels, endings and finishing what you write
Menu

Home / Chapters

Endings

Unreliable narrators and the ending that changes everything

When the narrator cannot be trusted, the last pages decide what the whole book meant. Four novels, from The Good Soldier to Atonement, and the reread effect.

Every first-person novel asks for trust. The narrator says this happened, then this, and we believe it, because there is nobody else in the room to ask. An unreliable narrator is one who abuses that trust, whether by lying, by not understanding what he sees, or by keeping something back until the last possible moment.

The ending is where the abuse comes due. In an ordinary novel, the last chapter resolves the story. In a novel with an unreliable narrator, the last chapter often resolves the narrator instead: it shows us who has been talking to us, and that changes what every earlier page meant. The book you finish is not quite the book you started reading.

This piece looks at four novels where that happens, roughly in order from the gentlest unreliability to the most complete. Each section carries a spoiler flag where the book is less than about fifty years old, and I would honor them. These are books whose endings are worth meeting cold, even for someone like me, who usually reads the last page first.

The Good Soldier: the narrator who forgets the death

Ford Madox Ford's novel (1915) opens with one of the most famous first sentences in English: "This is the saddest story I have ever heard." Its narrator, John Dowell, is an American who spent nine years in a close friendship with an English couple, Edward and Leonora Ashburnham, without understanding that his wife and Edward were lovers.

Dowell tells the story out of order, circling back, correcting himself, contradicting what he said a chapter before. He is unreliable less because he lies than because he did not see, and still does not quite see, what was in front of him.

The ending is a masterpiece of this. Dowell seems to finish. He sums up, notes that he is now a nurse-attendant to a young woman who pays no attention to him, and calls it the end of his story. Then the last section begins: "It suddenly occurs to me that I have forgotten to say how Edward met his death." He goes on to describe, in the same mild voice, standing in a stable while Edward reads a telegram, takes out a small penknife, and asks Dowell to take the wire to Leonora. Dowell does not try to stop him. The book's last sentence has him trotting off with the telegram.

The reread effect here is total. Once you know that Dowell watched his friend go to his death and walked away, every expression of sentimental affection earlier in the book sounds different. You start to ask what else he forgot to mention, and why. The text is in the public domain and free at Project Gutenberg, and it is a better second read than first.

The Remains of the Day: the narrator who cannot say it

Spoilers for the ending of The Remains of the Day follow.

Kazuo Ishiguro's novel (1989), which won the Booker Prize that year, is narrated by Stevens, an aging English butler on a motoring trip through the West Country. He has two subjects he will not look at directly: his long service to Lord Darlington, whose politics in the 1930s ruined his reputation, and his feelings for Miss Kenton, the housekeeper who left Darlington Hall years before.

Stevens is unreliable through self-deception. He tells us what he did and said, often accurately, but he keeps misreading his own motives. The reader sees what he cannot.

Near the end, he visits Miss Kenton, now Mrs Benn, in Cornwall. She admits that she has sometimes wondered about the life she might have had with him. He tells us, almost in passing, that his heart was breaking, and then he says nothing to her about it. Afterward, on a seafront bench, a stranger tells him that the evening is the best part of the day. Stevens concedes, for the first time, that he trusted Darlington so completely that he has nothing of his own dignity left to show. And then he resolves to improve his service to his new American employer.

The ending works because the narrator finally admits the truth and then immediately goes back to work. The admission is real, but it changes nothing in how he will live. A first reading makes it sad. A second reading, with the ending in mind, makes every polite deflection in the first two hundred pages unbearable.

We Have Always Lived in the Castle: the narrator who knew all along

Spoilers for the ending of We Have Always Lived in the Castle follow.

Shirley Jackson's novel (1962) is narrated by Mary Katherine Blackwood, called Merricat, who is eighteen. She lives with her older sister Constance and their Uncle Julian in the family house outside a hostile village. Six years earlier, most of the family died of arsenic in the sugar bowl. Constance was tried and acquitted, but the village still believes she did it.

Merricat's voice is charming, odd and full of private magic: buried objects, protective words, rules about the days of the week. The reader notices early that she is strange. What the reader may not notice, because she never says it outright, is that she was the poisoner. Near the end, after a fire, a mob and Uncle Julian's death, Constance tells her she has always known, and Merricat admits it. She put the arsenic in the sugar because Constance never takes sugar.

What makes this ending unusual is that it does not punish the narrator or rescue the reader. The sisters move back into the burned house and live in what is left of it, while the villagers, ashamed, leave food on the doorstep. Merricat narrates all this as a happy ending, and in her terms it is one. The reader has to hold two readings at once: a story of sisterly devotion, and a story of a murderer who got exactly what she wanted. Jackson's achievement is that neither cancels the other.

Atonement: the narrator who wrote the book

Spoilers for the ending of Atonement follow.

Ian McEwan's novel (2001), shortlisted for the Booker Prize, is mostly told in the third person, so its unreliability is hidden in plain sight. In 1935, thirteen-year-old Briony Tallis accuses Robbie Turner of a crime he did not commit, and in doing so separates him from her sister Cecilia. The later sections follow Robbie in the retreat to Dunkirk and Briony as a trainee nurse in London, and the third part ends with Briony visiting the reunited lovers to begin making amends.

Then comes a coda, "London 1999," in Briony's own first-person voice. She is seventy-seven, a successful novelist, newly diagnosed with vascular dementia. She reveals that the three preceding parts are her novel. Robbie died of septicemia at Dunkirk. Cecilia was killed months later when a bomb destroyed Balham Underground station. The reunion never happened. Briony invented it, she says, as a last kindness to them.

This is the most complete version of the effect: the ending does not just change our view of the narrator, it reveals that there was a narrator at all. Every scene we read as fact becomes a choice Briony made, including the ones that flatter her. And the question the title asks, whether a writer can atone through fiction, is handed to the reader without an answer.

What these endings share

Put side by side, the four endings follow a pattern.

Novel How the narrator is unreliable What the ending reveals What changes on a reread
The Good Soldier Did not see, tells out of order His passive part in a death His affection reads as evasion
The Remains of the Day Self-deceiving He knows what he lost Every courtesy reads as loss
We Have Always Lived in the Castle Withholding She was the poisoner Charm reads as menace, and still as charm
Atonement Authorial, hidden The story is her invention Every scene reads as a choice

In each case the final revelation is prepared. Dowell's forgetfulness is visible from the first chapter. Stevens's deflections are almost comic before they turn sad. Merricat's rituals point at guilt long before Constance names it. Briony's habit of making stories is the first thing we learn about her. A twist that is not prepared feels like a trick. A revelation that is prepared feels like recognition, the sense that the book was telling you all along and you were not listening.

That distinction matters for the wider argument about ambiguous endings, which I wrote about in Open or closed: what an ambiguous ending owes the reader. An unreliable narrator can close a story completely and still leave its meaning open, because the facts are settled but the judgment is not.

Questions readers ask

Is it cheating for a narrator to hold back the truth until the end?

It depends on whether the clues were there. Readers forgive a withholding narrator when a second reading shows the truth was visible all along. They resent one when the ending depends on information the book actively hid. All four novels above survive the reread test.

Should I read these books twice?

If you can, yes, and ideally close together. The second reading is a different book. Clementine Oduya's piece on reading the last page first makes a case that knowing the ending can deepen the pleasure, and these novels are the strongest evidence for it.

Can a third-person novel have an unreliable narrator?

Atonement shows that it can, if the third person turns out to belong to someone. Most third-person narration is not unreliable in this sense, but a novel can be told through a character's limited view so closely that the reader shares her mistakes.

Which of the four is the best introduction?

I would start with The Remains of the Day. Its unreliability is gentle and human, and the ending lands without any trickery at all. The Good Soldier is the one to read after it, once you know what to listen for.

More pieces on last chapters, epilogues and the endings that divide readers are on the endings shelf.

Beatrix Hallam

Beatrix writes about how novels close: last chapters, epilogues, the endings that divide readers and the ones that settle into memory. She reads the final page first more often than she admits.